×

Proving Wrongful Death: Elements and Negligence

Proving Wrongful Death: Elements and Negligence

In an immensely difficult legal case like holding someone liable for the death of your loved one, it can be hard to navigate the specifics of proving your case. Proving wrongful death requires showing certain elements, including duty of care, a negligent action, damages, and most crucially, that those damages were because of that negligent action. You should understand the elements that make up a wrongful death case to help prove your case.

The Four Elements of Wrongful Death

A wrongful death claim filed in a civil court must prove crucial elements. Even if your case is being negotiated outside of court, having these elements is necessary to have a strong case and recover damages. The four aspects you have to prove include:

1. Duty of Care

First, you must prove that the allegedly at-fault party owed the deceased person a duty of care. A duty of care is a legal standard to act in a specific way, but it varies depending on the relationship between parties and the jurisdiction.

Medical providers usually owe a duty of professional care to their patients, while companies that make consumer products generally have a duty of care to prevent the sale of unreasonably dangerous products. All of these duties of care may differ depending on the state you are filing in.

2. Breach of Duty

You must then prove a breach of that duty of care. In most wrongful death cases, the allegedly at-fault party behaved or failed to behave in a negligent way. Negligence means they failed to act as most reasonable people would in a similar situation, and this behavior breached the duty of care they owed to the party.

Drivers who operate their vehicle while texting, otherwise being distracted, or being impaired breach their duty of care to others. A medical provider may breach their duty of care to a patient by failing to diagnose a medical condition despite clear evidence of the condition.

In very rare situations, a breach of duty occurs because of criminal negligence or malicious and intentional behavior.

3. Causation

Then, you have to prove that the other party’s negligence caused the incident where your loved one was injured or died, or that it was one of several causes. If death or injury would have occurred regardless of the person or company’s carelessness, then that party cannot be held liable.

This element is often the deciding factor in whether or not a wrongful death case is successful. Arguments against this element often include blaming other parties in the incident, including the deceased person. Strong evidence is needed to help prove causation.

4. Damages

The last element is that you must prove that because of the incident, you suffered measurable damages, or economic and non-economic losses. The death of your loved one likely resulted in legally recognized losses like a loss of financial support, the cost of funeral services, the cost of a burial or cremation, and the emotional trauma of losing a loved one and their support. Depending on your jurisdiction, you could recover these and other damages.

The Burden of Proof

To prove each of these elements, you must provide evidence that shows it by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning it is more likely than not that the claim is true. This standard must be met by each individual element.

FAQs

What Do You Need to Prove Wrongful Death?

The evidence you need to prove wrongful death will vary depending on the specific case and how the accident occurred.

Evidence can include testimony from eyewitnesses who saw the incident, medical documentation, workplace incident reports, the autopsy, police reports of the accident, digital communications between parties, and photographs or video of the scene of the incident. It can also include professional expert testimony, such as from accident reconstructionists or the healthcare professionals who provided treatment.

What Are the Key Elements of a Wrongful Death Claim?

The key elements of a wrongful death claim include 1) an owed duty of care, 2) a breach of that duty, 3) the breach causing the accident where the individual was killed or injured, and 4) the damages the family suffered as a result of the loss of their loved one.

What Are the Odds of a Successful Wrongful Death Claim?

The odds of a successful wrongful death claim depend entirely on your specific case. You need to prove the key elements of the claim, using evidence like video of the incident, forensic evidence, eyewitness statements, and many other elements. You are also more likely to succeed when you work with an attorney.

How Long Does the Average Wrongful Death Case Take?

The average time that a wrongful death case takes will depend entirely on your specific case. These cases could be resolved quickly or take months to negotiate or litigate. While resolving a case quickly may seem beneficial at first, it often means settling for compensation that will not make up for your family’s long-term financial losses.

Hire a Wrongful Death Lawyer: The Importance of Local, Experienced Legal Representation

Depending on where you file your wrongful death case, certain elements can differ. Different states have unique standards of care that they hold medical providers to, for example. This changes what you have to prove in a wrongful death claim. There are also unique deadlines for these claims. That’s why it’s essential that you hire a wrongful death lawyer who handles cases in your area.

In Flathead County, there were sadly 23 fatalities from car accidents in 2024, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, and 202 vehicle occupant deaths in Montana from vehicle accidents the same year, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The CDC also reported 215 deaths from unintentional falls in the state.

If you lost a loved one and are filing a claim in Montana or Oregon, Bliven Law Firm, P.C. can give you the local legal representation you need. Our firm has spent over 35 years serving these areas and helping individuals and families navigate these impossible situations.

We want to help you get the answers you need at this time, providing you with experienced legal guidance and support. Our firm provides at-home or hospital visits if you need them. When you need professional and compassionate legal care, reach out to Bliven Law Firm, P.C.

Recent Posts

Featured Insight

Categories

Archives

Let Our Team Be Your Advocates

If you have been injured by a car wreck or suffered any type of serious injury, call our Kalispell personal injury lawyers at 406-755-6828 or fill out the
no-obligation online case form. We will respond promptly. When you hire our firm you will have the confidence of knowing that assisting you and resolving your
situation and claim is our priority. Contact us for your free case evaluation today.